The Who, last Friday, released a live album culled from a performance at New York’s Shea Stadium in 1982 from the tour in support of It’s Hard. It seems like it was only last year I was writing about the Who’s live album, The Who Live With Orchestra. Oh, wait a minute that was last year. This new live album from a much older performance entitled, Live At Shea Stadium 1982, is the audio portion of a DVD/Blu-Ray released a number of years ago. I don’t tend to focus on DVD/Blu-Ray releases but now that the Who have released this historical document as an album, I was interested.
The early 80s were a tough period for the Who and for Pete Townshend in particular. The venerable band had lost drummer Keith Moon on September 7th, 1978, just three weeks after they’d released Who Are You. The cover photo of the band had Moon sitting backwards on a folding chair with the words “Not To Be Taken Away” on it. Sadly the rock Gods weren’t paying attention to that and the Who lost a generational talent on drums – much like Zeppelin did a few years later with John Bonham.
After that, Townshend began to struggle with addictions to booze and heroin. Struggling to figure out the Who’s relevance in the world, he reignited his solo career in 1980 with Empty Glass which had hits like “Rough Boys” and “Let My Love Open The Door (To Your Heart).” Empty Glass was a full on rock album aimed at solo stardom which was a far cry from his more personal, acoustic debut, Who Came First. The band was a bit miffed that some of the tracks he used on the solo album weren’t done within the band which caused a lot of tension in an already tense band. To replace Moon, the band recruited former Faces drummer Kenny Jones. While I love the Faces, and like Jones, he was a much more conservative drummer than Moon… but then again who isn’t?
With Townshend spiraling downward in addiction and seemingly more focused on his solo career, the band’s future was in question. The Who put out Face Dances in 1981 and it was a little less bombastic than their previous work. Personally, I love Face Dances (it’s one of my “Dirty Dozen” LPs that only I like), but it came out when I was in junior high school, and we always love whatever was “then-current.” But that album divided fans quite a bit. Critics hated it. Kenny Jones, the new guy, began to publicly accuse Townshend of hording his best material for his solo career, an accusation Jones had previously leveled at Rod Stewart when he was in the Faces. Different band, same complaint. To make matters worse, Daltrey didn’t like Jones and when he told Townshend it was “Jones or me,” Townshend told him he’d keep Jones instead of Daltrey. Wow? The only guy who seemed to hold his shit together during all of this inter-band strife was bassist John Entwistle. He continued to hold down the bass line and was contributing great songs like “You” and “The Quiet One.”
In 1982 Townshend kicked heroin and in June of that year released his next solo album, All The Best Cowboys Have Chinese Eyes. Then, merely a few months later, the Who released what was to be – for a while – their final studio album, It’s Hard. Again, critics weren’t thrilled but I liked it. I loved the first single “Athena” and the title track. This album came out just as I was going to college. I remember working in the kitchen where I lived and “Eminence Front” came on the radio. It was the first time I’d heard the song… I looked at my coworkers in that hot, humid kitchen and everybody’s head was bobbing and people were dancing around like we were the cast of The Full Monty. That’s when I finally bought the album, early fall of ’82, and once again Entwistle had contributed great tracks in “Dangerous” and “It’s Your Turn.”
Sadly, I was away in college for my freshman year that fall and didn’t get to see the Who on that tour. I had missed them on the Face Dances tour due to some nefarious circumstances. I wasn’t to see the Who live until 1989 when they went on a tour with a band so large it looked like an orchestra. The press was pretty savage to the Who on that 1982 tour. The word was the Who was spent force creatively. Townshend had moved on, they were going through the motions, etc. It didn’t help that the live album culled from the tour, Who’s Last, tended to validate what was being said. Although admittedly, it’s been a really long time since I’ve heard that one. I remember seeing some live video of the Who from the tour and it was the first time I’d heard “Naked Eye” which is a fabulous tune from Odds & Sods, and it drove me to go buy that album so it couldn’t have been all bad… but I digress.
Knowing all of this made me feel more than a little trepidation when I approached Live At Shea Stadium 1982. Although, admittedly, the Who’s opening band on that tour, the Clash, put out a live album from their set at Shea and it was, to my ears, fabulous. The Clash were hated by the Who fans, it was a very difficult tour for them and yet they rose above it and just rocked. Would the Who do the same? Indeed they would.
I will admit, up front, that I was a surprised this live album is as enjoyable as it is. It’s no Live At Leeds, but few bands have a live album that great… (our list of favorite live LPs, here). I’ve always said great bands can “bring it” live. There’s just something that happens, that may be magic or may be chemistry, when four or five guys get up on that small stretch of ground we call, the stage, and play together. Even at their most troubled the Who turn in quite a show here. First and foremost, they switched up the playlist every night and played a bunch of different songs throughout the tour so they sound fresh. Townshend plays some kick ass lead guitar on this album. It’s a great reminder that the man is a guitar hero. Daltrey is in good voice. Jones drumming is solid, not flashy, but it does the job. And of course, John Entwistle is just nails on bass. Tim Gorman plays the keyboards. This band, these great musicians, still managed to jell despite the strife.
The set opens with “Substitute” and “I Can’t Explain.” How are you not going to love those songs? They’re both muscular performances you’d expect from the Who. I like that they play music from their then-current LP, It’s Hard. “Dangerous” penned by Entwistle is an early highlight. “Sister Disco” is always a highlight. I love that Entwistle sings on “The Quiet One” from Face Dances. I can only listen to a band’s greatest hits played live so many times so I appreciate the deeper tracks on this live album. “It’s Hard,” and “Eminence Front” are great here – especially the latter track. They just kill on that track, especially the guitar…”The sun shines, and people forget…”
There’s a short Quadrophenia set with “I’m One,” “The Punk And The Godfather” and finally “Drowned.” “Drowned” in particular turns into a great jam. I love that they dig deep and play a few of tracks also done on Live At Leeds, “Young Man’s Blues,” “Summertime Blues” and “Tattoo.” There are so many great tracks here from “Baba O’Riley” to “Who Are You.” The only track that seems to miss the mark for me was “Long Live Rock” which was a surprise. They play “Naked Eye” toward the end and it’s a great version of that song. Worth the price of admission, as the saying goes. Two of the last three tracks are Beatles’ covers, “Twist and Shout,” and “I Saw Her Standing There” which sound like good fun. Townshend in particular seems to be having a lot of fun on those tracks.
All in all this is a great, lively performance from a band who had been declared dead at the time. My only complaint is that they cut “Athena” from this set – the song was played at the show. I’ve seen the video footage of that on YouTube, and I liked it. It’s a bit of a disappointment it’s not here, although Daltrey never liked the song. Also, it’s worth mentioning, I streamed this album and there is a gap between every song (like a studio album) and it is annoying as hell. I like the crowd noise between songs on a live album… if I have enough bourbon I start to feel like I’m there. I’ve heard the CD/album versions do not suffer from this issue.
In the end, my complaints are “nits.” This is a great band rocking out in front of 70,000 of their closest friends. Turn this one up loud and enjoy! The Who were always a great band. Thankfully, this wasn’t the end for them. I really enjoyed WHO, which probably is their last LP. I’m delighted we’ve got this archival release from 1982 to rock along to.
Enjoy, Cheers!